In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
Options
Which scope for .338 Winchester Magnum?
TWalker
Member Posts: 2,372 ✭✭✭✭✭
I own a Ruger "All-Weather" stainless Model 77 MK II in .338 Winchester caliber. I have three scopes to choose from. Which would you pick for hunting deer, elk, and maybe bears? The 3-9x40 Leupold Vari-X II that's already on it, a 1.5-5x20 Vari-x III I just bought, or a M8 4x that I've had a while? Thank you for your suggestions.
Comments
Your question is without background information & thus un-answerable.
To be of the optimum use to it's owner, a rifle must have a sighting system that suits it's owner. The caciber will determine what the rifle is suitable for. The sights will aid him in acomplishing that purpose.
The various sighting systems are:
Open sights
Peep sights
ghost ring sights
holographic
red dot
scope (which includes 1x thru hi-power magnification)
The short version is: optics on a rifle is a crutch, just like the glasses on my face. I am an old GEEZER & I need opticaly compensated sights to put sights & target on one plane. If you are young & have good eyes, you don't need a scope for the average conditions. Start using a scope now, & you'll always need a scope (crutch)
Do you hike in to hunt? (no scope will keep the weight down)
Do you hunt in brush? (scope adds extra hang-ups)
What is the expected weather? (rain & cold can fog or cloud a scope)
If you answer the following questions, we can give you an educated opinion to answer your original question.
Eyes (near sighted or far sighted) do you wear glasses?
Maximum & minimum ranges this rifle will be used
Is weight a factor? Do you hike long distances with your rifle?
Will you be using this rifle for "dangerous game" protection?
The question that should be asked here, is "What is the maximum distance that you are comfortable shooting from?". If it is 250 yards or less I would go with the 1.5-5 x20 Vari-X III; 250 or more and I would choose the 3-9 x 40 Vari-X II. Fixed power scopes are no longer my first choice, as modern variable power scopes are as rugged as anything you are going to need, and are more flexible. As far as relative brightness between the two, the minimum exit pupil on the 1.5-5 is 4.0 and on the 3-9 it is 4.4, which I would call a wash do to the Vari-X III's better lens coating. Here's another thought: I would take the 3-9 out and view a roughly 20" object through it at your maximum shooting distance. Start at 9x, and turn the power ring down until you no longer feel comfortable that you can consistently make the shot at that power. If you are at 5x or less, I'd go with the Vari-X three due to it's lighter weight.
This is how it'll end up: (all Leupolds)
1100 slug gun: 2.5x20 fixed compact
.458 Magnum: 1.5-5x20 Vari-X III
.338 Magnum: 3-9x40 Vari-X II
7400 M7400 30-06: M8 Fixed 4X
How's that?