In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
Options
Smith & Wesson .22 Top Break Revolvers?
milsurplus
Member Posts: 221 ✭✭✭
Cant seem to find any info on Smith & Wesson .22LR Top Break Revolvers, were there any ever made?
I want to get something of better quality than my Harrington & Richardson 999 Sportsman .22LR top break revolver, even as nice as it is by no means is even close to the quality and fit and finish of a Smith & Wesson?
Thanks.
I want to get something of better quality than my Harrington & Richardson 999 Sportsman .22LR top break revolver, even as nice as it is by no means is even close to the quality and fit and finish of a Smith & Wesson?
Thanks.
Comments
Double action .22 revolvers just seem to not be that popular in general right now. This is probably in part because the simple blowback actions makes .22 autos relatively cheap.
Pretty much nobody is making ANY top-break revolvers anymore, with the exception of a few Navy arms repro guns in older low-pressure black powder rounds such as .38 special, 45LC, and .44 Russian. I think Uberti (ie Beretta) has a model like this too. Smith put out an older top-break repro a few years ago for a limited time, but in was in some obscure caliber. None of these guns are inexpensive.
There is a modern design Russian top break in .38./357 called the mp412 though its not legally importable into the USA. I have no idea how strong this gun really is:
The reasons for this are pretty simple. The top break action, in general, isn't as strong as modern DA designs, and today's guns operate at much higher pressures than the older black powder rounds. It doesn't make sense to spend tons of money on R&D creating a new top-break design then tooling up for it, when demand for these is so low.
While .22 would seem to be an ideal caliber for a new design top-break, I think the low demand for .22 DA revolvers in general makes this a losing business proposition. I don't think a top break design is going to result in a cheaper gun, and in fact, the converse is probably true.
Personally, I'd love to buy a modern recreation of one of the older .22 top break SINGLE SHOT guns. Even though production (and therefore retail) costs of this kind of single-shot should be really low, I'm probably the only nut who'd actually buy it, so I'm not holding my breath.
They put some .22 single shot barrels on revolver frames for slow fire target shooting.