In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
.22 snap caps or spent case?
Henry0Reilly
Member Posts: 10,878 ✭✭✭
My nephew said someone in a gun shop told him that snap caps do not protect .22 firing pins as well as using a spent case.
I can't help but think it was just something they said to excuse why they don't carry them.
I can't help but think it was just something they said to excuse why they don't carry them.
I used to recruit for the NRA until they sold us down the river (again!) in Heller v. DC. See my auctions (if any) under username henryreilly
Comments
Drywall Anchors. They will even feed through a .22 magazine, with no problem. When you manually operate the slide.
Great idea. Thanks.
Brad Steele
http://www.larrysguns.com/Products/Chamber-Plugs__LGI.aspx
I pack the 22 shell with a wad of paper (toilet or tissue) so the crap don't get knocked out of the empties. I also rotate the empty so the firing pin has a nice fresh spot to squish.
I like the dry wall anchor but empty 22 shells are free [:D]. Yeah I know I'm cheap.
Use spent cases-they're free and work. Anchors don't.
Drywall anchors do not provide adequate cushioning for the firing pin. The pin just penetrates the plastic.
Use spent cases-they're free and work. Anchors don't.
Don't agree. Used these anchors many times. Very resilient plastic. Firing pin won't penetrate the plastic, with just one hit. I usually rotate them, any way.
It depends alot on the physical characteristics, of the firing pin point though. Some have almost a sharpened point. Others are wide and flat. Even with the sharpened point, the plastic will stand up to at least one hit.
quote:My nephew said someone in a gun shop told him that snap caps do not protect .22 firing pins as well as using a spent case.
I can't help but think it was just something they said to excuse why they don't carry them.
In my opinion, having tried both, I think the converse is true.
One hit on a spent shell, and the rim is crushed, and you probably need to rotate it. On the other hand, you can fire the plastic snap caps more than once without having to rotate it. How many times is going to depend on the shape and force of the firing in pin, in question, but you usually get a "few" hits (maybe 3. . .) before having to rotate the gun.
So from that perspective, spent shells are less safe, because your more likely to dry fire one twice in the same spot and hurt the firing pin of your gun.
In practice, I think the plastic snap caps are just fine. . .they act as a good cushion for the firing pin, and I've never heard of a case where someone damaged a gun by using them appropriately.
One other big advantage (IMO) of the snap caps is that once in the gun, they're obviously dummies. . .IE being brightly colored they don't look like live ammunition the way spent shells do. That has obvious safety implications, for example in being able to ascertain that guns are truly safe easier, and also to prevent what might be termed "overfamiliarization" with dry firing onto real brass. IE, if you get too used to doing that, one day you might make a "bad" mistake.
Disadvantage of snap caps, other than cost, is that the rims get chewed up and can, in certain cases, make them harder to remove, or even have small pieces of plastic flake off inside the gun. (Though usually even the "chewed" ones stay together.