.40 cal. VS .45 cal

Gene B.

Would you the .40 cal has the same stoping power as a .45 even if the .40 is a little smaller.

dheffley

Go to www.evanmarshall.com/ and look at the real world statistics on stopping power. The .45 has more energy than the .40. They are pretty close though.

---

Save, research, then buy the best.Join the NRA, NOW!Teach them young, teach them safe, teach them forever, but most of all, teach them to VOTE!

royc38

No.

shane

I can buy 45s from WOLF alot cheaper than those puney 40s of any brand. I see no reason to own a 40cal at all.

dheffley

shane,I agree that .45ACP is the better choice, but "puney" on the .40 S&W would depend on which end of the muzzel you were on.

---

Save, research, then buy the best.Join the NRA, NOW!Teach them young, teach them safe, teach them forever, but most of all, teach them to VOTE!

M.Opaliski

They'll both kill you dead just the same, which would you rather be shot with ... choose the opposite.

---

Support your RKBA ... MatthewNRA Life MemberTalk Radio Junkie opaliski@hotmail.com TheFirearmsEnthusiast

BigTex

The .40 is just the 10mm's * offspring, if you are gonna do it, don't do it half-azzed, go with the 10mm.Regards,BigTex

TED GAR

The 40 will kill humans, but dont go hunting with it. If you are after hogs, use the 45, it will knock em down!

rg666

Here's a fair example. 40 cal 180grain bullet at max load 944fps 45 cal 185grain bullet at max load 924fpsNot a big difference as you can plainly see. How about magazine capacity? The typical 40 cal gun comes with at least 10 round's. The typical 45 8 rounds. To be specific you can find 12 round mags for the 40 & 45 in some cases. How about cost of ammo? 45 cal has got to be far more popular, thus cheaper. Now you have the facts. You decide!!!! RG

Richie Rich

I have both and love to shot both .But I carry the 45.(BIGGER IS BETTER)

---

"The Constitution of most of our states(and the United States)asserts that all power is inherent in the people;that it is their right and duty to be at all times armed."--Thomas Jefferson--

TED GAR

Yep, bigger is better, If you get a 180 grain 9mm at 945 fps, it still will not equal the stopping power of a 45 acp.

TED GAR

if you want more capacity, sure get the 9mm in 15 round capacity, or the 40 in ten round capcity, but they make 10 round mags as well for the 45 acp.

gundummy

why carry so much extra? 8 each .45 is all I carry in my Sig, but one is all I need for a crook, unless there are 7 more of them. Obviously, I prefer the .45, but no matter how much rounds you carry, it does not mean a thing if you can't hit your target.GD

TED GAR

That is exactly my point. My sig has 8 round capacity, and my trusty colt has 7 round capacity. That is all I need.

mudge

The 9MM's usually have a higher capacity magazine because you have to hit your target more times to get the same effect as one .45 round. You're usually not having to defend the entire neighborhood single handed so why all the ammo? If you can't stop the threat with 8 rounds of .45, it better be "feets don't fail me now!!!"Mudge

---

I can't come to work today. The voices said, STAY HOME AND CLEAN THE GUNS![This message has been edited by mudge (edited 10-19-2001).]