In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
antiques at online stores, how much nego room?
Silver Star 5301
Member Posts: 47 ✭✭
When comparing prices of antique and collectibles- mostly on GunBroker, I will check for them at grabagun, gunsinternational and the others. It seems to pricing is pretty salty and a lot of guns don't sell.
I am curious if there is a general rate if inflated pricing, in which an interested buyer and negotiate on. I am more interested in how much over-value they are listed for, to help me decide on bidding elsewhere.
I have seen some items on GunBroker relisted numerous times at no reserve, but high beginning bids. when relisted, the beginning bid is lowered, and sometimes at no reserve/penny start. It seems what the sell originally wanted is close to twice what it ends up selling for.
Any experts have advice on how you see through the smoke and fog of all that? I am bidding on some great bucket-list items at different sites.
I am curious if there is a general rate if inflated pricing, in which an interested buyer and negotiate on. I am more interested in how much over-value they are listed for, to help me decide on bidding elsewhere.
I have seen some items on GunBroker relisted numerous times at no reserve, but high beginning bids. when relisted, the beginning bid is lowered, and sometimes at no reserve/penny start. It seems what the sell originally wanted is close to twice what it ends up selling for.
Any experts have advice on how you see through the smoke and fog of all that? I am bidding on some great bucket-list items at different sites.
Comments
Unfortunately many sellers on GB are delusional, and don't recognize the above.
Like it or not. The actual fair market value of a particular item. In most cases. Is established, by the final open bidding price, realized on the auction.
The problem with the negotiating concept. Is that it cuts the auction out of the equation. The folks that run the auction, aren't stupid. IMHO, if most buyers and sellers can get away. With cutting a private under the table deal. Without involving the auction, they will do it.
James
My dad was a great haggler, I don't think he ever bought anything at a gun show or sold much either without haggling about the price.
I received a substantial promotion after 30 years of effort, and one if my pleasures is to occasionally buy an antique. being in the old car hobby, I know the factors that determine value and have seen neophytes make some poor purchases. I see the potential for a mistake in the realm of 1873 Winchesters, and after buying a good one for a fair price, I shy away.
Once again my main question is : are the items for sale on the online sites a good estimator for deciding on an auction bid, or are most of those sellers in fantasy land?
Once again my main question is : are the items for sale on the online sites a good estimator for deciding on an auction bid, or are most of those sellers in fantasy land?
My opinion is no, most of those prices are not an indicator of actual value.
To find real world prices, you can search "completed" auctions here on GB. This will show what actual selling prices are.
If you like an antique gun, pay what you are willing to for it, not what somebody else might pay. Buy it because it is something you like, but the days of considering it an investment have passed. Much like the market for older collector cars.
Of course in the past, I gauge how I feel when I am outbid. Relieved? Done bidding on it.
I did pass this week on an antique on GB, as I was gauging it against a very similar item elsewhere. The one on GB sold for what willl ikely be 30% less than the auction house item.