In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
Options
M14 (M1A) forged parts or cast
U.s.M.c. 54
Member Posts: 28 ✭✭
Hello to all , have a Springfield Inc. M1A , why did they use a cast trigger housing ? is forged that much better in a part like this ? would it be wise in the long run to replace it with a GI trigger group ? info on what other parts are cast and what to avoid in buying extra parts would be great.........Thank You.
Comments
Before someone goes into a long explanation in cast vs forged, most will tell you forged is stronger, period. The strength of a forging is designed into the part to be optimized. A forging has grain flow, as does a piece of wood. A forging is stronger in some directions (hopefully the important directions) and weaker that a casting in some ways. A casting's strength is not dependent on the grain flow, and has realtively equal strength in all directions. A forging's strength is resisting forces perpendicular to the grain flow. In that direction, a forging is stronger than a casting.
If you wanted a forged receiver and parts on a rifle based on Garand design, you should have bought a Springfield Armory or RSI BM59. Or the receiver on a Chicom M14S is forged, and actually amoung the best receivers available for this type of rifle. Any problem with Chinese M14 style rifles does not involve their receivers, contrary to popular opinion.
The older M1As do have more MIL-SPEC parts, as the surplus parts dried up, they started using more and more cast and imported parts on their rifles. If I was to buy one, I'd be looking for one of the earlier ones, rather than a new rifle.
A new Springfield Armory M1A is a nice rifle, but not as nice as the earlier ones, and there are better "M14 style" receivers out there. An M14 style rifle built up with a Chicom receiver and using MIL-SPEC parts is actually a better rifle than the Springfield Armory. The Fulton Armory upgrades to M1A or Chicom M14S have a reputation for being expensive, but good. Due to price, I don't recommend them, but there is some good info on their web site.
http://www.fulton-armory.com/indexf-special.htm
To err is human, to moo is bovine.