Pick just 1

garanch

If you were going to buy one of the following 6 guns at the price listed which one would it be? And why? All guns are New.

NAA Black Widow in 17HMR - 250.00
Walther P22 5" - 280.00
Springfield 1911 45 Stainless - 670.00
Magnum Research BFR in 45/70 - 790.00
Smith & Wesson 686 - 450.00
Ruger Blackhawk 45LC - 480.00

iwannausername

The 686 - its a classic

n/a

The BFR...b/c I want one.[;)][:p]

Warbirds

The springfield 1911, just because I'm overdue for another 1911.

sig232

I would buy the Ruger Blackhawk in 45 LC. Want it in Stainless, 5 1/2" barrel and with the bisley grip. Just because its so easy and fun to reload and one heck of a hoot to shoot!

Has a nice sound when you touch off those rounds. Kind of like my Harley!

tazzer

quote:Originally posted by badwrench
The 686, 'cause I kick myself for selling mine.


That makes two of use.[:(!][:(!]

He Dog

686 because by comparison the others are also-rans.

mrseatle

The P22 cause they are going for 325 around here.

yearofspider

The Ruger Blackhawk 45LC be cause I don't have one....yet[:p]

1911a1-fan

my pick?

duh!

Daddie_Tom

The 686. Cause the one I have now has a scope on it.

bpost

686, everything else can wait

bigal125

Ruger Blackhawk 45LC - 480.00 - sounds like what I need/want!

Big Al (Bisley grips would be okay, but blued, definitely blued)

tapwater

It would be the 686......if I hadn't bought one 5 years ago, as new in the box for $180......[^]

zr700

The 17HMR because I need bear protection [;)]
Actualy I would take the 1911[:)]

William81

The 686 hands down.....

BlueTic

BFR - I've had the rest!!!

CLINTF

Probably the 686 because it's a well made nicely finished paper puncher. If I was considering a hunting handgun I'd go with the BFR.

p3skyking

The Springfield 1911A1 .45 of course.
It's the only pistol a man needs.

wanted man

Originally posted by ECC:

The BFR...b/c I want one.
Eric
allamericanarmsco@frontiernet.net


+1[:)]

Frogbert

The Springfield .45, expecially if it's this one:


SSChampionCustomLoadedPX9142L

9mmsmith

686 always a good choice.

shellitout

Springfield 1911 45 Stainless [:D]

DarkStar11

686 -- its just a great gun. I'm not sure you can have too many .357's.
2nd would be the BFR.

wizard78

If they were new, the 686. Mine needs company. If they were used, NONE. I don't pay retail. Prices are to high for used.

He Dog

Hey, if you put BlackRoses on that list it would change my choice. Heck if I had her, she would be out buying me a couple of guns a week. I sure ain't figured out how Classic pulled that off. She is sure good hearted, but that woman must be blind![}:)]

Cubslover

P22, sweet looking gun. A friend of mine is going to buy one this weekend. It's aroung $339 here.

garanch

The tally so far:

Smith 686 - 13
Springfield 1911 - 6
Ruger Blackhawk - 4
BFR - 3
Walther - 2
Black Widow - 0

gap1916

Walther P22 5". Most fun to shoot, Lest exspensive to shoot, Best to train wife or girl friend to shoot. My 2 cents [8D]

CHGOTHNDER

Walther P22 5" - 280.00, I have the rest.

PJ

Colonel Plink

The Springfield. Hands down.

garanch

As far as prices go, isn't the 1911 by far the best deal?

reddnek

Ruger 45LC though I'd rather have a 44 mag

garanch

Smith 686 - 13
Springfield 1911 - 7
Ruger Blackhawk - 5
BFR - 3
Walther - 4
Black Widow - 0

rob223

The 686. It is more versatile in use of ammo. Plus I do like the S&W wheel guns.
Brian