In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
Tribe Seeks Greater Freedom to Kill Eagles
allen griggs
Member Posts: 35,690 ✭✭✭✭
from Yahoo.com
Tribe Seeks Greater Freedom to Kill Eagles Mon May 22, 7:09 PM ET
JACKSON, Wyo. - The Northern Arapaho Tribe and a man accused of shooting a bald eagle on the Wind River Indian Reservation say the federal government should make it easier for American Indians to apply to kill bald eagles for use in religious ceremonies.
The tribe has filed a brief in the case of Winslow Friday, who allegedly shot the eagle without a permit in March 2005, and planned to make its arguments before U.S. District Judge William Downes on Monday.
The case moves forward as the federal government considers removing protections for bald eagles as a threatened species. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is taking public comments on the proposal through June 19.
Federal law allows enrolled tribal members to get a permit to kill bald eagles in certain cases. But Friday and the Northern Arapaho say there is no clear way to apply for the permit. They also say the bald eagle population in Wyoming and other states has grown large enough to enable some of the birds to be killed with little harm to the species.
In the federal government's response, Assistant U.S. Attorney Stuart Healy said allowing people to shoot eagles without permission would undermine the current balance between preservation and religious freedom.
Healy argued that there was no evidence Friday was selected to hunt an eagle or that he had purified himself prior to shooting the eagle. Purification is said to be necessary for the eagle to be used in a ceremony, Healy wrote.
Also, also noted the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service maintains a repository in Denver of eagles shot illegally or killed by cars or power lines. Friday and the Northern Arapaho say relying on the eagle repository results in long delays and that those eagles can't be used in some traditional ceremonies.
If convicted, Friday faces up to a year in jail and a fine up to $100,000.
Bald eagles were listed under the Endangered Species Act in 1978. They were reclassified from endangered to threatened in 1995 and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service now estimates that more than 7,700 nesting pairs of bald eagles inhabit the lower 48 states.
Even if bald eagles were removed from Endangered Species Act protection, they would continue to be protected by the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act.
Tribe Seeks Greater Freedom to Kill Eagles Mon May 22, 7:09 PM ET
JACKSON, Wyo. - The Northern Arapaho Tribe and a man accused of shooting a bald eagle on the Wind River Indian Reservation say the federal government should make it easier for American Indians to apply to kill bald eagles for use in religious ceremonies.
The tribe has filed a brief in the case of Winslow Friday, who allegedly shot the eagle without a permit in March 2005, and planned to make its arguments before U.S. District Judge William Downes on Monday.
The case moves forward as the federal government considers removing protections for bald eagles as a threatened species. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is taking public comments on the proposal through June 19.
Federal law allows enrolled tribal members to get a permit to kill bald eagles in certain cases. But Friday and the Northern Arapaho say there is no clear way to apply for the permit. They also say the bald eagle population in Wyoming and other states has grown large enough to enable some of the birds to be killed with little harm to the species.
In the federal government's response, Assistant U.S. Attorney Stuart Healy said allowing people to shoot eagles without permission would undermine the current balance between preservation and religious freedom.
Healy argued that there was no evidence Friday was selected to hunt an eagle or that he had purified himself prior to shooting the eagle. Purification is said to be necessary for the eagle to be used in a ceremony, Healy wrote.
Also, also noted the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service maintains a repository in Denver of eagles shot illegally or killed by cars or power lines. Friday and the Northern Arapaho say relying on the eagle repository results in long delays and that those eagles can't be used in some traditional ceremonies.
If convicted, Friday faces up to a year in jail and a fine up to $100,000.
Bald eagles were listed under the Endangered Species Act in 1978. They were reclassified from endangered to threatened in 1995 and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service now estimates that more than 7,700 nesting pairs of bald eagles inhabit the lower 48 states.
Even if bald eagles were removed from Endangered Species Act protection, they would continue to be protected by the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act.
Comments
What is the Federal Government doing, placing their laws on a Free Nation?
Didn't we screw them enough?
At this time in history,I see no reason to kill "insert species here"-not even for religious rituals.
Isn't that closer to what you intended? Because that is where it will end up "my religion forbids the use of pork", "my religion forbids the killing of cows", "my religion worships chickens", etc etc. The PC train only rolls down hill.
If they are no longer an endangered species, what harm is there in letting a few be harvested? This seems to be more meaningful than most hunts, and the bird's death would not be in vain.
And besides, they taste a lot like spotted owls.[;)]
I hope they didn't waste the meat.
Clouder..
like the guy who wants to be a poligamist because his religion alows it...or maybe within their sect sex with 10 year old boys is ok....screw your religious freedom and the indians can bite me. I don't think God wants his name used to bend alter boys over the back pew and he doesn't want it used to reenact cave dweller fantasys of a better life in the happy hunting grounds. If he did we would allow lsd crazed pot smoking pedifiles to live harmoniously in west texas towns while they force feed arsnic laced grape koolaid to underage virgins in a fertility ritual that culminates with the sacrefice of every first born male child with brown hair and homosexual tendancies....
You smoke some eagle some before you stuff that eagle? I'm out, but I could send you some deer smoke...
most liberals want federal law to ban ANYTHING religious. if the federal government allows a bald eagle to be killed for a religious celebration wouldnt that be "endorsing a religion" ? clear violation of seperation of church and state
separation of church and state is a two way street. while government should not endorse a religious practice niether should it restrict the right to practice as you wish...laws are an aside. laws ment to protect species, property rights, protection from hatred, should not be violated in the persuit of a persons religion or lack there of
What do they do for fun?
Go Go Gophers watch 'em go go go!
Screw those Indians and their "special" rights. They claim to be sovereign nations but they always have their hands out for ol' white eyes' money.
you get to the demming casino much?
What is the Federal Government doing, placing their laws on a Free Nation?
Didn't we screw them enough?
X-RING!!
quote:jsergovic Posted
What is the Federal Government doing, placing their laws on a Free Nation?
Didn't we screw them enough?
X-RING!!
Unfortunately, and like the wild mustang, the range of eagles is not limited to Wampum City and free indian nations; when either animal is killed while on indian land, for whatever reason, the surrounding nation is affected, and this not any less than an indian nation would be affected if the surrounding nation dumped garbage on the tribal council lawn. I think this has always been the problem with "free indian nations": myopia and selfishness. Instead of watching only Wes Studi movies and blowing away any eagles that happen to fly by, maybe indians should curb their religion and stick to building bigger tax-exempt casinos.
Clouder..
anyone ever been to new mexico ? those indians down there are the most sorry bunch of people i have ever seen, they make ghetto blacks look like royalty. its sad really.
Blame this on the White Man. Drug abuse, alchoholism, unemployment, suicides are the norm for the Native Americans unlucky enough NOT to have have built a casino. It is a sad statement about our country.
As other members posted, we have screwed them enough.
Not all, but many tribes have used eagle feathers and other misc. animal parts for religious ceromonies eons before the White Man stole their land. I see no problem in letting them continue to follow their religious ceromonies on their land.
Sure. Why not? All the ills of the world are the fault of the white Anglo-Saxon male.
There's plenty of eagles in Alaska. On Adak they were eating out of the dumpster behind the galley. I thought one was going to attack me because I walked too close to it and his ham bone. Pretty buzzards.
I actually have a picture of them doing just that...if I can find it I will post it.....it's from dutch harbor
Maybe Benjamin Franklin had a better idea.
Now you're talkin' turkey.
Clouder..
Maybe Benjamin Franklin had a better idea.
Then the wild turkey would be protected because of it's "national bird status."
They'd do the same with the starling.