In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
Cylinder chatter...how much is too much?
espo28
Member Posts: 44 ✭✭
OK, I'm starting to regret my decision to by a Colt .45 SAA
First I notice that the loading gate isn't quite right, now I notice that the cylinder chatters a bit more than I would have expected. Not extreme, but, enough if you pick up the gun quickly, you can hear the cylinder move a tiny bit. I don't know if I'd call it a rattle but you get my drift.
Anyway, how much chatter is acceptable? Should it even be present in a brand new $1400+ Colt or is this to be expected given their apparently loose tolerances (which I've been told they are noted for...)
And lastly, is this a fixable problem? I intend to return it to Colt anyway for the loading gate problem, and will have them look at this also, but was wondering if there was anything simple I could do to reduce the amount of chatter in the meantime.
Thanks!
Espo
First I notice that the loading gate isn't quite right, now I notice that the cylinder chatters a bit more than I would have expected. Not extreme, but, enough if you pick up the gun quickly, you can hear the cylinder move a tiny bit. I don't know if I'd call it a rattle but you get my drift.
Anyway, how much chatter is acceptable? Should it even be present in a brand new $1400+ Colt or is this to be expected given their apparently loose tolerances (which I've been told they are noted for...)
And lastly, is this a fixable problem? I intend to return it to Colt anyway for the loading gate problem, and will have them look at this also, but was wondering if there was anything simple I could do to reduce the amount of chatter in the meantime.
Thanks!
Espo
Comments
I think it's more important that the cylinder locks up tight when the revolver is cocked.
No doubt, no doubt...and it does lock-up well, but the chatter still bugs me in the uncocked position. Maybe I'm just being too *, but I wanted to get your expert opinions on the matter. Don't want to be unfair to Colt, just want my fair share of a tight cylinder [:)]
quote:Originally posted by hughbetcha
I think it's more important that the cylinder locks up tight when the revolver is cocked.
No doubt, no doubt...and it does lock-up well, but the chatter still bugs me in the uncocked position. Maybe I'm just being too *, but I wanted to get your expert opinions on the matter. Don't want to be unfair to Colt, just want my fair share of a tight cylinder [:)]
If you like getting cocked in a tight cylinder, maybe you should become a Muslim terrorist. They get 72 virgins, you know.
[/quote]
Hell, just 72? What am I supposed to do the REST of the week? [}:)]
[If you like getting cocked in a tight cylinder, maybe you should become a Muslim terrorist. They get 72 virgins, you know.
quote:
Hell, just 72? What am I supposed to do the REST of the week? [}:)]
Soak your hands in warm water to get the cramps out. [:D] (Sorry, couldn't resist)
Does this also happen with the gun cocked?
None of these should happen with a new SAA Colt
What are you calling chatter? Is it forward and aft play in the cylinder or looseness when you try to rotate the cylinder?
Does this also happen with the gun cocked?
None of these should happen with a new SAA Colt
Its the looseness that you feel when trying to rotate the cylinder. It is most noticable when the gun is in the uncocked position. In the cocked position it seems much better, but still a verrrrrry slight movement can be felt.
And I would agree, I'm thinking the cylinder should sit like a rock in either hammer position.
Looseness in which direction? You've got to be more descriptive if you want help or advice.
Ok, sorry if I wasn't clear. When the gun is in the uncocked position...I grip the cylinder with index finger on one side and thumb on the other. Then I attempt to rotate it clockwise...it moves a bit to that direction...if I go the other way (counterclockwise) it then moves a bit that way. Also, if I take the gun firmly in my hand and shake it, you can HEAR (and feel it) move a bit. I'm sure there is a correct gunsmithing term for this, but I called it "chatter" out of ignorance more than anything else! [:(]
ps Yeah, I have probably had one too many>