In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
Why do they make holsters like this one???
n/a
Member Posts: 168,427 ✭
This is the only holster I can find for a S&W 329 NG that rides low enough to carry a pack with...and even it rides a little high for packs that are designed to work with a gun belt. For the life of me, I cannot figure out why they left the trigger exposed.?.? If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, you are looking at a disaster.
The other problem with this holster is the fact that it's completely enclosed on the bottom...which is going to trap dirt, debris, etc.
I've only found one other option and that's a Galco Holster made specifically for S&W (I bought it through S&W's website). It's a strong side belt holster and it rides way too high for a pack...it also doesn't completely cover the barrel. It has an open bottom to allow debris to fall out, but it leaves a half inch of the barrel and the front sight exposed.
The other problem with this holster is the fact that it's completely enclosed on the bottom...which is going to trap dirt, debris, etc.
I've only found one other option and that's a Galco Holster made specifically for S&W (I bought it through S&W's website). It's a strong side belt holster and it rides way too high for a pack...it also doesn't completely cover the barrel. It has an open bottom to allow debris to fall out, but it leaves a half inch of the barrel and the front sight exposed.
Comments
If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, you are looking at a disaster.
So tell me, how does the tree branch press the trigger when at the same time it is lifting the gun from the holster?
quote:Originally posted by ECC
If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, you are looking at a disaster.
So tell me, how does the tree branch press the trigger when at the same time it is lifting the gun from the holster?
Obviously you haven't spent much time hiking in the rugged Rocky Mountains. Half the time I'm crawling through brush so thick you can's see 5' in front of you...the other half the time, I'm falling down, etc. etc.
quote:Originally posted by Odawgp
quote:Originally posted by ECC
If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, you are looking at a disaster.
So tell me, how does the tree branch press the trigger when at the same time it is lifting the gun from the holster?
When it comes to EEC, anything is possible.
Oh I have no doubt, he can probably even get a primer to go bang while crushing it in a bench top vice [B)]
quote:Originally posted by Odawgp
quote:Originally posted by ECC
If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, you are looking at a disaster.
So tell me, how does the tree branch press the trigger when at the same time it is lifting the gun from the holster?
Obviously you haven't spent much time hiking in the rugged Rocky Mountains. Half the time I'm crawling through brush so thick you can's see 5' in front of you...the other half the time, I'm falling down, etc. etc.
only 32yrs (grew up in Utah hunting the Unitas and live in Colorado in which I have no doubt is every bit as rugged as Idaho)
long enough to know that what you say could happen is statistically nearly almost as impossible as it is physically impossible
try it with an unloaded gun,, no wait better yet us a plastic one I'd hate to hear you shot yourself with an completely unloaded firearm
http://www.epsaddlery.com/pc-72-20-77-tortilla-holster.aspx
This is full on protection but might be a little too slow for a fast draw.
http://www.epsaddlery.com/pc-88-26-2000-full-flap-holster.aspx
I use El Paso's holsters but I think you really should take a look at the suggested Simply Rugged stuff--it should be exactly what you are looking for in their Sourdough line http://www.simplyrugged.com/store/index.html
Also their Chesty Puller rig might be better for someone with a backpack on.
He talks to Gawd on a daily basis.
That in itself, is enough for me to keep my distance.
Wise man...didn't think I'd ever say that to you.[;)]
quote:Originally posted by ECC
quote:Originally posted by Odawgp
quote:Originally posted by ECC
If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, you are looking at a disaster.
So tell me, how does the tree branch press the trigger when at the same time it is lifting the gun from the holster?
Obviously you haven't spent much time hiking in the rugged Rocky Mountains. Half the time I'm crawling through brush so thick you can's see 5' in front of you...the other half the time, I'm falling down, etc. etc.
only 32yrs (grew up in Utah hunting the Unitas and live in Colorado in which I have no doubt is every bit as rugged as Idaho)
long enough to know that what you say could happen is statistically nearly almost as impossible as it is physically impossible
try it with an unloaded gun,, no wait better yet us a plastic one I'd hate to hear you shot yourself with an completely unloaded firearm
It's easily possible...and likely to happen. I wouldn't trust this holster in the conditions I bow hunt in.
...neither would the customer I initially ordered it for.
Look at the Don Hume H-717. They are open bottom and cover the trigger.
I don't see the 329NG listed, but I will call them to see if they have one available for that gun. It would be nice to have better barrel coverage, but that holster does ride lower and would be better with a pack.
quote:Originally posted by Odawgp
quote:Originally posted by ECC
quote:Originally posted by Odawgp
quote:Originally posted by ECC
If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, you are looking at a disaster.
So tell me, how does the tree branch press the trigger when at the same time it is lifting the gun from the holster?
Obviously you haven't spent much time hiking in the rugged Rocky Mountains. Half the time I'm crawling through brush so thick you can's see 5' in front of you...the other half the time, I'm falling down, etc. etc.
only 32yrs (grew up in Utah hunting the Unitas and live in Colorado in which I have no doubt is every bit as rugged as Idaho)
long enough to know that what you say could happen is statistically nearly almost as impossible as it is physically impossible
try it with an unloaded gun,, no wait better yet us a plastic one I'd hate to hear you shot yourself with an completely unloaded firearm
It's easily possible...and likely to happen. I wouldn't trust this holster in the conditions I bow hunt in.
...neither would the customer I initially ordered it for.
Get with the program...here, I'll type slowly so you can follow...
What Odawgp is saying is that If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, it will require more force to pull the trigger in double action than it will to pull the gun from the holster. Therefore, the gun will be yanked from the holster long before the trigger makes the gun go bang. Very heavy trigger pull on the 329 night guard.
swhat they make pockets fir E.
quote:Originally posted by ECC
quote:Originally posted by Odawgp
quote:Originally posted by ECC
quote:Originally posted by Odawgp
quote:Originally posted by ECC
If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, you are looking at a disaster.
So tell me, how does the tree branch press the trigger when at the same time it is lifting the gun from the holster?
Obviously you haven't spent much time hiking in the rugged Rocky Mountains. Half the time I'm crawling through brush so thick you can's see 5' in front of you...the other half the time, I'm falling down, etc. etc.
only 32yrs (grew up in Utah hunting the Unitas and live in Colorado in which I have no doubt is every bit as rugged as Idaho)
long enough to know that what you say could happen is statistically nearly almost as impossible as it is physically impossible
try it with an unloaded gun,, no wait better yet us a plastic one I'd hate to hear you shot yourself with an completely unloaded firearm
It's easily possible...and likely to happen. I wouldn't trust this holster in the conditions I bow hunt in.
...neither would the customer I initially ordered it for.
Get with the program...here, I'll type slowly so you can follow...
What Odawgp is saying is that If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, it will require more force to pull the trigger in double action than it will to pull the gun from the holster. Therefore, the gun will be yanked from the holster long before the trigger makes the gun go bang. Very heavy trigger pull on the 329 night guard.
That's potentially possible and I understood what he meant...but it's not a guarantee. Guns don't always come out of their holsters easily. It doesn't take much of a bind to keep a gun in a holster...
http://www.ar15armory.com/forums/Joined-club-finally-t71267.html
One like this one
http://www.ar15armory.com/forums/Joined-club-finally-t71267.html
That would be nice...unfortunately, Galco does not offer the DAO for the 329 NG.
You won't catch me hiking the woods in any other type of setup.
"Don't leave home without it"
Joe
quote:Originally posted by dano
quote:Originally posted by Odawgp
quote:Originally posted by ECC
If the thumb snap happens to come open and the a tree branch snags the trigger, you are looking at a disaster.
So tell me, how does the tree branch press the trigger when at the same time it is lifting the gun from the holster?
When it comes to EEC, anything is possible.
Oh I have no doubt, he can probably even get a primer to go bang while crushing it in a bench top vice [B)]
while also being under water.
Why not get the right holster for the gun?
uh...I think that's the point of this entire thread...
quote:Originally posted by grumpygy
One like this one
http://www.ar15armory.com/forums/Joined-club-finally-t71267.html
That would be nice...unfortunately, Galco does not offer the DAO for the 329 NG.
Did you read the peice or just look at the Pretty Picture. He also uses it for his 329ng. That would mean the pistol he now uses it for must be listed so you just get it for that and it fits yours.
quote:Originally posted by ECC
quote:Originally posted by grumpygy
One like this one
http://www.ar15armory.com/forums/Joined-club-finally-t71267.html
That would be nice...unfortunately, Galco does not offer the DAO for the 329 NG.
Did you read the peice or just look at the Pretty Picture. He also uses it for his 329ng. That would mean the pistol he now uses it for must be listed so you just get it for that and it fits yours.
Galco makes that Holster (the DAO) for the 4" 329 PD, the 629, and other N Frames...but you've got an extra couple inches of holster. It's an option, but my objective with the 329NG was to get as light and compact as possible for packing around these mountains.
Thanks for the feedback/idea though![:)]
Obviously you haven't spent much time hiking in the rugged Rocky Mountains. Half the time I'm crawling through brush so thick you can's see 5' in front of you...the other half the time, I'm falling down, etc. etc.
I've been that drunk a time or two.
quote:Originally posted by ECC
Obviously you haven't spent much time hiking in the rugged Rocky Mountains. Half the time I'm crawling through brush so thick you can's see 5' in front of you...the other half the time, I'm falling down, etc. etc.
I've been that drunk a time or two.
Do you road hunt the rest of the time?
If U no like,U no buyeeee.
It has to be leather, then?
That's what I prefer...
http://kramerleather.com/productDetail.cfm?productID=19&categoryID=26&make=SMITH & WESSON&model=329PD .44 4&CFID=22034559&CFTOKEN=50126970
Looks like Police model to me.
If U no like,U no buyeeee.
Actually, I ordered this one in for a customer and he didn't want it after seeing the exposed trigger. I have yet to find the "ideal" replacement.
A custom holster is an option...and the Don Hume tip may pay off. I have to call them tomorrow...the Simply Rugged is a possibility as well.
That's one of the reasons I like GB...we have a diverse group of people with a wide base of knowledge about various things. One can get quite a bit of feedback about almost anything. We've got quite a few jerks too...some of which posted in this thread, but the good folks still outnumber the jerks...
quote:Originally posted by fishkiller41
Looks like Police model to me.
If U no like,U no buyeeee.
Actually, I ordered this one in for a customer and he didn't want it after seeing the exposed trigger. I have yet to find the "ideal" replacement.
A custom holster is an option...and the Don Hume tip may pay off. I have to call them tomorrow...the Simply Rugged is a possibility as well.
That's one of the reasons I like GB...we have a diverse group of people with a wide base of knowledge about various things. One can get quite a bit of feedback about almost anything. We've got quite a few jerks too...some of which posted in this thread, but the good folks still outnumber the jerks...
Eric,
I have a Simply Rugged Sourdough holster on the way for my 329NG. I also have one coming from Lobo Gun Leather. They make a number of styles for the 329NG. I've got a 1-SL-X on order for the 329NG.
Nice stuff.
quote:Originally posted by ECC
quote:Originally posted by fishkiller41
Looks like Police model to me.
If U no like,U no buyeeee.
Actually, I ordered this one in for a customer and he didn't want it after seeing the exposed trigger. I have yet to find the "ideal" replacement.
A custom holster is an option...and the Don Hume tip may pay off. I have to call them tomorrow...the Simply Rugged is a possibility as well.
That's one of the reasons I like GB...we have a diverse group of people with a wide base of knowledge about various things. One can get quite a bit of feedback about almost anything. We've got quite a few jerks too...some of which posted in this thread, but the good folks still outnumber the jerks...
Eric,
I have a Simply Rugged Sourdough holster on the way for my 329NG. I also have one coming from Lobo Gun Leather. They make a number of styles for the 329NG. I've got a 1-SL-X on order for the 329NG.
Nice stuff.
Thanks for the feedback.[8D]
quote:Originally posted by Colonel Plink
quote:Originally posted by ECC
Obviously you haven't spent much time hiking in the rugged Rocky Mountains. Half the time I'm crawling through brush so thick you can's see 5' in front of you...the other half the time, I'm falling down, etc. etc.
I've been that drunk a time or two.
Do you road hunt the rest of the time?
That's funnier than you could ever know. When I have time, I'll email you the details of my one and only elk hunt. It was a whole lot like that[:D]
"Why do they make holsters like this one???"
In my honest opinion it would seem that they make holsters like this one to, um, holster your firearm, maybe, possibly just might be the reason they make 'em...., just saying you know that might be the reasoning behind its manufacture and if you really want to think hard about it you might come to the same conclusion....[:D]
As far as trigger exposure, which was your second question posited to the forum, even I, a simple female can see that the hammer appears to be locked by the design of the holster, thus preventing a mistaken trigger pull? You really worry me sometimes. [;)]
No one here ever answered the original question:
"Why do they make holsters like this one???"
In my honest opinion it would seem that they make holsters like this one to, um, holster your firearm, maybe, possibly just might be the reason they make 'em...., just saying you know that might be the reasoning behind its manufacture and if you really want to think hard about it you might come to the same conclusion....[:D]
As far as trigger exposure, which was your second question posited to the forum, even I, a simple female can see that the hammer appears to be locked by the design of the holster, thus preventing a mistaken trigger pull? You really worry me sometimes. [;)]
Is being female the reason you are having issues with reading comprehension[:X][:D]. I'd suggest re-reading the OP.
I have one of these type holster for a J frame and a kydex one that covers the trigger guard completely.
truth be told I rather wear and carry the one that doesn't cover the trigger guard
makes drawing of a revolver much faster, I don't have to reposition my hand a second time to get a good grip on the gun like I do if I draw from the kydex holster
As far as bow hunting and bust'n brush so thick one can't see five feet I will just call "horse apples"
The bow hunters I know and are sneaky and tend to make it a habit to go around areas such as you describe. but most have the common sense god gave a rock
all the fun'in aside
I have one of these type holster for a J frame and a kydex one that covers the trigger guard completely.
truth be told I rather wear and carry the one that doesn't cover the trigger guard
makes drawing of a revolver much faster, I don't have to reposition my hand a second time to get a good grip on the gun like I do if I draw from the kydex holster
As far as bow hunting and bust'n brush so thick one can't see five feet I will just call "horse apples"
The bow hunters I know and are sneaky and tend to make it a habit to go around areas such as you describe. but most have the common sense god gave a rock
Not around here...I can guarantee you. I do appreciate your feedback on the holster though.