In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
Who's the best QB... Brees, Brady or Rodgers?
toolmaniam
Member Posts: 3,213
My vote goes to Brady. He's about as steeled as someone can be under pressure. Also a great leader.
Comments
Brady, as tool mentioned is as "steeled" as they get. His respect would improve if: 1. He had a much better pass defense. 2: If he could keep his zipper up.
Brees has a great & accurate arm. Lost today but it just isn't about wins & losses.
Rogers has a great control of the game and has the respect of the GB fans. Not easy following Starr & and Farve.
"Best" is tough to evaluate because it's a team game.
Today, I would say Manning (hurt status considered).
NS
Upon further consideration, I would choose Brady, as I would get be around his wife in the owners sky box during games.[:D]
His ratio of completions vs. picks and red zone. He's awesome.
We will see again tomorrow.
Youth is on Rodgers side if you're looking long term.
Who's playing next week??????????
[:D][:D][:D][:D]
Of those 3, let see,
Who's playing next week??????????
[:D][:D][:D][:D]
So Brady did that all on his own?
I'd say the complete collapse of the Colts absent Manning indicates more about how good Peyton Manning is, then the Patriots advancing in the play offs indicates how good Brady is.
Brady benefits from a great cast of characters around him, including a football genius for a Head Coach. This accentuates how good Brady is, not sure he's the best of the current crop though.
I think Drew Brees is a stud. He shows alot of heart.
I think a healthy Peyton Manning surrounded by some of the talent at that Tom Brady has would be the best performing Quarterback.
Tebow? [:D][:D][:D]
NS
He did win a playoff game this year....[}:)][:0]
Point well taken, but, at some point you have to decide exactly what criteria you'll use to determine the best. Being rather lazy, and likely more ignorant than the average, I'll go with the ability to use your own talents and those of your team mates to generate wins.
[:D]
shilowar,
Point well taken, but, at some point you have to decide exactly what criteria you'll use to determine the best. Being rather lazy, and likely more ignorant than the average, I'll go with the ability to use your own talents and those of your team mates to generate wins.
[:D]
I don't disagree that winning it all has to be taken into consideration. It's really subjective, one could come up with unlimited standards to come to a answer.
Talk about "all time" for a second and I would pick Dan Marino or Joe Montana.
Let's talk coaches. My vote is for Tom Coughlin. IMO he gets more out of mediocre talent but Belechick.....
Fourth and 20, :11 seconds left, on the 40 yard line, down by 4? He's the guy.
However, I really can't recall ever seeing Brady under pressure. The amount of time he had to get rid of the ball in the game against the Broncos was incredible. That offensive line could make any average quarterback look like a star worthy of a nice fat contract. Umm, anybody remember Matt Cassel? Need I go on?
Yes, Brady is the most overated QB ever. I'd love to see him play behind an average to below average O-line where he has to run for his life several snaps a game. I don't think he'd last.