In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
Options
Fake 03A4 (Part 2)
nmyers
Member Posts: 16,880 ✭✭✭✭
This is a photo of the model markings on a genuine 03A4.
As Mr Builder said, the rifle listed for sale is a fake. The model markings are those of an 03A3, that has been altered. It appears that a SN within the 03A4 range has been added to the right side of the receiver, since the SN for an 03A3 is directly under the scope base.
The tan color junk in the receiver appears to be Lubriplate AA-130, AKA "snowmobile grease", which is still used by some old time shooters.
Neal
EDIT: Some members will recall that we had a discussion of a fake Colt 1911 about 2-3 years ago. (The owner had just bought it from a local auction for several thousand $ as an investment.) She & the auctioneer were sure that it was genuine, but I was able to get her a written statement from the reputable shop manager WHO HAD REFINISHED THE GUN. It's not always that easy. The 1903A4 is an obscure collecting area, & there aren't that many folks familiar with them. I would never expect GB auction management to get into expertizing guns based on out-of-focus photos. If you are going to buy an expensive gun from a seller who posts poor quality photos & whose guaranty is AS IS, you better know what you are doing.
As Mr Builder said, the rifle listed for sale is a fake. The model markings are those of an 03A3, that has been altered. It appears that a SN within the 03A4 range has been added to the right side of the receiver, since the SN for an 03A3 is directly under the scope base.
The tan color junk in the receiver appears to be Lubriplate AA-130, AKA "snowmobile grease", which is still used by some old time shooters.
Neal
EDIT: Some members will recall that we had a discussion of a fake Colt 1911 about 2-3 years ago. (The owner had just bought it from a local auction for several thousand $ as an investment.) She & the auctioneer were sure that it was genuine, but I was able to get her a written statement from the reputable shop manager WHO HAD REFINISHED THE GUN. It's not always that easy. The 1903A4 is an obscure collecting area, & there aren't that many folks familiar with them. I would never expect GB auction management to get into expertizing guns based on out-of-focus photos. If you are going to buy an expensive gun from a seller who posts poor quality photos & whose guaranty is AS IS, you better know what you are doing.
Comments
Scope issues aside, I'd look at that thing and not touch with a ten foot pole. It's a parts gun at this point. Just owning the receiver, if the serial has been ground and re-stamped and not filed with the BATF could I believe land the owner in a lot of hot water.
I guess no one bothered to show it to Support?
Obviously none of us can say for sure what the others have done privately, but nobody has posted that they reported this in the other thread.
So its safe to assume that nobody has, I think.
Should we be "policing" the boards in this way?
Personally, I don't know anywhere near enough about these particular rifles to even have spotted the fake, let alone be comfortable reporting it.
I am right there with you, but at least one forum member has declared this item to be a fake. If he knows that, and believes that there is a shifty seller on the auctions, he should report it to Support.
A while back, a seller here, {well known} had a Kriegsmarine Ramdon pistol listed.
It was a out and out fake, and not a very good one at that.
In the forums, after the shameless plug for it, I posted it should be researched because I said those pistols are restamped to increase the value and maybe the listing should be changed.
After about 10 or 12 more postings how good the seller is, I just
plain called it a "fake".
My post was deleted.
That $500 pistol sold for { IIRC ] around $1500.
From now on, I and many others will just stay out of it.
There is an outfit that is commercially reproducing A4's on A3 actions. I'm quite sure they are not remarking them, though. I saw a short film clip where a WWII sniper was recently presented with one.
A while back, a seller here, {well known} had a Kriegsmarine Ramdon pistol listed.
It was a out and out fake, and not a very good one at that.
In the forums, after the shameless plug for it, I posted it should be researched because I said those pistols are restamped to increase the value and maybe the listing should be changed.
After about 10 or 12 more postings how good the seller is, I just
plain called it a "fake".
My post was deleted.
That $500 pistol sold for { IIRC ] around $1500.
From now on, I and many others will just stay out of it.
Mr. babun, it appears that you didn't understand my post, or maybe I wasn't clear enough. This place, GunBroker forums, is not auction support. Support is found at the "Help" link at the top of each auction page.
If one sees an auction that he believes is fraudulent, he does not have to put anything about it on the forums, and in reality, he should not. What he should do, is send the auction number to Support, and let those guys check it out. They will, and they will NEVER come down on you, or call you stupid. Rather, they will thank you for bringing it to their attention. You may never know what was done, but you can always re-visit the auction to see if it is still there.