Different types of brass for reloading

sf340flyer

As a new reloader, can anybody tell me the advantages (or disadvantages) of reloading "nickel" vs. regular brass. I primarily reload the 40 S&W if it matters in this case.

badboybob

Nickel looks pretty, but usually doesn't last as long as brass. I've found that brass can be reloaded 15 times or more.

PC=BS

jager22

i have heard that nickel plated brass will chip and get stuck in or scratch the inside of your dies

king999

Probably the best use for using both is to identify loads. For example, when I make up standard loads for .38 sp., I use brass, while I load +P in nickel.
Since the nickle is merely a thin plating on brass, there can be no significant difference in true strength or longevity, although one may work better through the loading dies.
Have fun, be careful!!
Morty

aby80

I've been loading .38 Specials for over 40 years and prefer nickle plated cases. Mainly because I don't have to tumble them as often to keep them nice looking. They do have a tendency to get cracks in the necks quicker than brass cases if you bell them too much. I have bought so many once fired cases of all calibers at a cheap price at yard sales, swap meets and at auctions that I throw away anything that does not clear my visual inspections after firing. Just my 2 cents worth.

Pearyw

I have used both brass and nickel 40 s&w cases, and have never really seen any difference. 40 s&w cases last a long time as long as you stay away from hot loads in a Glock. They tend to bulge at the base.

JIM STARK

I believe I read somewhere... The nickled brass has to be a few thousandths thinner, to allow the outside measurement to meet SAAMI (sp?) specifications..... ????

sf340flyer

Thanks for all the replies, very informative. Don't have to worry about using the 40 in a Glock, I shoot a Sig 226. (Don't personally care much for plastic)