In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
Options

colt agent 38spl.

NOAHNOAH Member Posts: 9,690
edited September 2012 in Ask the Experts
got a colt agent ,made around 1983-84 2" 38spl. snubbie
can i use +p ammo or not[?]

thanks
noah

Comments

  • Options
    rufe-snowrufe-snow Member Posts: 18,650 ✭✭✭
    edited November -1
    I wouldn't except in personal protection situations. They are alloy frame revolvers dating to the early 80's. This was prior to +P ammo being on the market and widely used, i.e if they weren't manufactured for +P don't use except in emergencies.
  • Options
    Riomouse911Riomouse911 Member Posts: 3,492 ✭✭✭
    edited November -1
    Agree, +P not a good idea in the older alloy frame guns...'specially a Colt where finding a good gunsmith for repairs is getting harder and harder to do.

    I suggest that you look for something like a Standard Pressure 110 grain Critical Defense (Hornady) or the like for decent personal protection, with minimal recoil, and less stress on your Agent.
  • Options
    victorj19victorj19 Member Posts: 3,642 ✭✭✭
    edited November -1
    I never thought about my 1st gen Colt detective not being able to handle +P loads.

    Should I avoid +P loads to?
  • Options
    CS8161CS8161 Member Posts: 13,595 ✭✭✭
    edited November -1
    quote:Originally posted by victorj19
    I never thought about my 1st gen Colt detective not being able to handle +P loads.

    Should I avoid +P loads to?


    The Det Special is all steel, correct? I would still not feed it a steady diet of plus p loads, but they are certainly fine for carrying for self defense.
  • Options
    511pe511pe Member Posts: 258 ✭✭✭
    edited November -1
    Because the gun isn't rated for +P your correct answer is no. The fallowing is for informational purposes only. I have personally used all lead .38 special+P rounds in an old alloy frame Colt Agent that was sold as a refurbishment. The store had acquired old retired service pistols form the local police department. There came to be a creation of a 158gn all lead semi-waddcutter hollow point(hope I spelled that right).38 special+P round specifically called the FBI round. Extensive tests revealed the 158gn all lead semi-waddcutter hollow point had expanded to about the size of a .45 in ballistics jelly. The test gun was a .38 snub-nose. If I remember correctly, +P ratings/markings might have came after this creation. Please understand that lead bullets are lubricated, so in theory produce less stress on the barrel. I personally wouldn't feel so confident with any jacketed +P rounds because although the jacket reduces the leading of the barrel bore it's much harder than Lead. A 2" barrel may be more forgiving because of the short barrel length. So in theory a lot can go wrong (except for an over pressurized load)with the ammo (such as a squib)and it may be safer than the same caliber in a longer barrel length. For self defense all lead hollow points would be the best for low pressure guns. Furthermore I believe a +P just uses a longer shell casing to create more case pressure and perhaps a little extra powder(please correct me if wrong). A reloader may not find them so desirable because a heaver grain bullet can be seated in such a way, closer to the chamber's end, and with a heavy crimp, it may lend it's self to accepting more powder within the safety margins. In my experiences longer case lengths may make the extraction more difficult especially in 6 shot revolvers. Be advised, if the Colt Agent brakes a part you might end up with a collectable or a parts gun. Kinda hard to find new replacement parts for that.
  • Options
    AnonymouseAnonymouse Member Posts: 4,050
    edited November -1
    quote:Originally posted by 511pe
    Because the gun isn't rated for +P your correct answer is no. The fallowing is for informational purposes only. I have personally used all lead .38 special+P rounds in an old alloy frame Colt Agent that was sold as a refurbishment. The store had acquired old retired service pistols form the local police department. There came to be a creation of a 158gn all lead semi-waddcutter hollow point(hope I spelled that right).38 special+P round specifically called the FBI round. Extensive tests revealed the 158gn all lead semi-waddcutter hollow point had expanded to about the size of a .45 in ballistics jelly. The test gun was a .38 snub-nose. If I remember correctly, +P ratings/markings might have came after this creation. Please understand that lead bullets are lubricated, so in theory produce less stress on the barrel. I personally wouldn't feel so confident with any jacketed +P rounds because although the jacket reduces the leading of the barrel bore it's much harder than Lead. A 2" barrel may be more forgiving because of the short barrel length. So in theory a lot can go wrong (except for an over pressurized load)with the ammo (such as a squib)and it may be safer than the same caliber in a longer barrel length. For self defense all lead hollow points would be the best for low pressure guns. Furthermore I believe a +P just uses a longer shell casing to create more case pressure and perhaps a little extra powder(please correct me if wrong). A reloader may not find them so desirable because a heaver grain bullet can be seated in such a way, closer to the chamber's end, and with a heavy crimp, it may lend it's self to accepting more powder within the safety margins. In my experiences longer case lengths may make the extraction more difficult especially in 6 shot revolvers. Be advised, if the Colt Agent brakes a part you might end up with a collectable or a parts gun. Kinda hard to find new replacement parts for that.


    Incorrect.
Sign In or Register to comment.