In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
High VS Low temperature reloading
dcloco
Member Posts: 2,967
What are the problems when working up loads in the summer versus the winter months?
Comments
The old time powders exhibited quite a bit of sensitivity to temperature variations....
Winter loading that were loaded 'hot' for 20 degree weather will often blow primers at 100 degrees next summer..I have had it happen.
Summer loadings will show as much as 200-300 fps slower velocities next winter.
The effects change with the different powders...and it is difficult to predict across the entire spectrum what will happen...the above is a generalized viewpoint of effects.
+1 on what highball said. I've had 400 fps difference with standard powder. Most notably with my favorites, IMR and Hodgdon 4895.
I've had such success with extreme 4350 this past winter and summer testing loads that I went and got 8# of the extreme 4895. I used same loads(4350) from -18F to +96F and got a maximum difference of 20 fps avg. That was loaded in three different cartridges, 7.5x55 Swiss, 7.65x53 Argentine and .257 Ackley imp. I have just started loading the summer tests for the H4895 extreme.
Conversely, I've generally only had about 100 fps difference from summer to winter with Vihtavuori powders. Again, these are temps from -10 or so up to +90 deg. In comparing cost effectiveness between the two I've found extreme and VV to be about equal. I get very good pressure form the VV, so it has generally taken a little less powder to get the same velocities as Hodgdon...generally, that's not a hard fast rule. -anyhow, hope that helps
I know a lot of the ball military powders were very temp sensitive due to their small size and lack of newer coatings. Like H870 would make a great summer load, but then fired in the winter would be slow and dirty.