In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
Bait Fishing and Release
woodguru
Member Posts: 2,850
What do you all think about a trout fisherman that uses power bait or nightcrawlers and releases good but damaged fish in order to catch bigger ones?
We were fishing at Rock Creek Lake in the Mammoth Lakes area in October when we saw a guy that had about 15 or twenty dead fish around him that were nice fat 2 pounders, he had a couple of three pound fish and a 4 or 5 pounder on the stringer.
He was in the prime spot that gives up a limit in about 20 minutes so when we got there and saw "our spot" taken we figured he'd be done in a few minutes. When we saw him ripping the hooks out of nice fish with pliers I was pissed. My wife's dad was telling me to leave it be when I said I was going to go tell him he was done. Finally after another 10 good fish I had had enough. Don was trying to stop me and my wife told him to leave me be that there was no way the guy would even argue with me.
I walked up to him and told him to pack up his stuff and go. He said he wasn't done and I told him yes you are done. He said he still had two fish to catch for a limit and I told him to get the two that were dying three feet away from the shore. He started yelling I couldn't make him go and I told him he was right, but that I could kick his * if he didn't. I told him I would have the store call the sheriff and game warden while I held his fat butt so they could see the 20+ dead fish floating and dying within sight of his spot.
He left cussing and swearing and giving me lip, but he left. We couldn't stand to see so many fat 2 and 2-1/2 lb fish go to waste so we took 15 (5 each) up to the house and came back to get the rest and fish long enough to finish out our limits from there, which was only a few fish each. We had a large bunch of family in two cabins so we were eating a fair amount of fish anyway.
People who have that kind of disregard for nice fish piss me off. They don't understand that's why people use artificial lures and flies so that smaller fish can be released. My wife and I keep even small fish if they have been hooked roughly. There is way too much denial amongst many fisherman that will try to tell you a fish will live when it doesn't have a chance.
We were fishing at Rock Creek Lake in the Mammoth Lakes area in October when we saw a guy that had about 15 or twenty dead fish around him that were nice fat 2 pounders, he had a couple of three pound fish and a 4 or 5 pounder on the stringer.
He was in the prime spot that gives up a limit in about 20 minutes so when we got there and saw "our spot" taken we figured he'd be done in a few minutes. When we saw him ripping the hooks out of nice fish with pliers I was pissed. My wife's dad was telling me to leave it be when I said I was going to go tell him he was done. Finally after another 10 good fish I had had enough. Don was trying to stop me and my wife told him to leave me be that there was no way the guy would even argue with me.
I walked up to him and told him to pack up his stuff and go. He said he wasn't done and I told him yes you are done. He said he still had two fish to catch for a limit and I told him to get the two that were dying three feet away from the shore. He started yelling I couldn't make him go and I told him he was right, but that I could kick his * if he didn't. I told him I would have the store call the sheriff and game warden while I held his fat butt so they could see the 20+ dead fish floating and dying within sight of his spot.
He left cussing and swearing and giving me lip, but he left. We couldn't stand to see so many fat 2 and 2-1/2 lb fish go to waste so we took 15 (5 each) up to the house and came back to get the rest and fish long enough to finish out our limits from there, which was only a few fish each. We had a large bunch of family in two cabins so we were eating a fair amount of fish anyway.
People who have that kind of disregard for nice fish piss me off. They don't understand that's why people use artificial lures and flies so that smaller fish can be released. My wife and I keep even small fish if they have been hooked roughly. There is way too much denial amongst many fisherman that will try to tell you a fish will live when it doesn't have a chance.
Comments
There needs to be a rule against this trophy killing. It circumvents the law and its wrong.
I would have run the dude off too.
I spent many hours on that lake.
An old boy that lived around there befreinded me. He was real bad
to drink. Usually carried a 1/2 pint of Jack in his tackle box
when he went out fishing with me. He had about six tackle boxes, and
they all contained antique lures that I marveled at. I should have
took what he offered to give me but I didn't. But he did leave a
little plastic box in my boat that never got back to him and it has
some of the smallest fishing hooks in it that I have ever seen. I
put on my glasses to look at them, and I have no idea what they would
be used for
I'd say fly tying too. Pop always said "U can catch a big fish,on a tiny hook but,U'll never catch a tiny fish, on a big hook"..
Your Pop was a wise man...