In order to participate in the GunBroker Member forums, you must be logged in with your GunBroker.com account. Click the sign-in button at the top right of the forums page to get connected.
The 10th Amendment
Henry0Reilly
Member Posts: 10,893 ✭✭✭
Why the devil aren't we challenging the UnConstitutional crap congress keeps enacting by filing suit under the 10th Amendment?
I used to recruit for the NRA until they sold us down the river (again!) in Heller v. DC. See my auctions (if any) under username henryreilly
Comments
The other end of this thing is...you will be suing the Beast in the Beasts' own Court....see how well THAT works out.
Henry,
While I agree 100% that many of the laws passed by Congress are unconstitutional, fighting them in a court would prove to be futile. Why? Well, let me give you a recent example:
D.C. vs. Heller
While some may consider this a "victory" for RTKBA, it is just the opposite. Mr. Heller took on the goverment, claiming that the D.C. gun laws were unconstitutional, and of course, he was right; they are unconstitutional. What Mr. Heller failed to realize is that all three branches; the executive, legislative, and judicial, are all linked, and the corruption present in one permeates into the others. Hence, you have a decision handed down by the judicial that left the door wide open for the legislative to create more restrictions, which will be enforced by the executive.
I agree there needs to be a restoration, but it will not occur in a courtroom.
[;)][;)]
quote:Originally posted by wsfiredude
Why the devil aren't we challenging the UnConstitutional crap congress keeps enacting by filing suit under the 10th Amendment?
Henry,
While I agree 100% that many of the laws passed by Congress are unconstitutional, fighting them in a court would prove to be futile. Why? Well, let me give you a recent example:
D.C. vs. Heller
While some may consider this a "victory" for RTKBA, it is just the opposite. Mr. Heller took on the goverment, claiming that the D.C. gun laws were unconstitutional, and of course, he was right; they are unconstitutional. What Mr. Heller failed to realize is that all three branches; the executive, legislative, and judicial, are all linked, and the corruption present in one permeates into the others. Hence, you have a decision handed down by the judicial that left the door wide open for the legislative to create more restrictions, which will be enforced by the executive.
I agree there needs to be a restoration, but it will not occur in a courtroom.
Why the devil aren't we challenging the UnConstitutional crap congress keeps enacting by filing suit under the 10th Amendment?
In a word, too much chance of losing. With four law-abiding justices on the Supreme Court (no other court matters, the pivotal issue will wind up with the Supremes), four scofflaw justices, and one weathervane who has no apparent legal compass, we can lose as many as we win... and those losses have a PERMANENT effect.
If Presiden McCain makes a few appointments to replace the justices most likely to retire (Souter, Stevens, Ginsburg), THEN will be the time to start bringing those 10th amendment suits. But not now, sorry.
You don't fight because you're pissed. You fight because you want to WIN.
LMMFAO!
THAT was a pretty funny joke you made.
[xx(]
Hmgh-Hmgh. Heh-Heh. Heh heh heh ha ha Bwwwwwwwhahahahahahahhahahah!
[:(!]
Then he misses that mccrud voted for ginsberg and byers...two of the most Socialist/Communistic pukes sitting on the court...
Yeah, Fremind; Little Acorn sems to be a good researcher..till its comes to mccrud.
Then he misses that mccrud voted for ginsberg and byers...two of the most Socialist/Communistic pukes sitting on the court...
There lays the problem with party hacks. The simply regurgitate what they are told to..
Kinda reminds me of the NRA types.
Why the devil aren't we challenging the UnConstitutional crap congress keeps enacting by filing suit under the 10th Amendment?
Because most of the internet extremist zealots are all talk, no walk, and the rest know that they're wrong even though they refuse to let go of the fantasies.
Nothing stops you from doing anything except your own unwillingness to do it. So why aren't YOU doing it?